Did Qatar Cheat?


If you haven’t heard about the controversy behind Qatar being chosen as the host country for the 2022 FIFA world cup by now then you must live under a rock or be an American. FIFA (Fédération Internationale de Futball Association) chooses the host country for their future world cups years ahead of time and when they selected Qatar as the host in 2010, skepticism broke out around the world. The main allegations following the decision were that the FIFA executive members accepted bribes from wealthy Qatari officials. It’s no secret that Qatar has billions of dollars in oil money and it also is no secret, to those who know a thing or two about the soccer world, that Qatar has never had a presence in the soccer community. So why did they want to host the World Cup so badly? What can they possibly gain from it? It’s not like they will suddenly have the inspiration to become the best international soccer team in the world, let alone the Middle East, or that they will gain much international recognition. Sure, maybe tourism will go up a bit but does that really matter? I believe that Qatar just wants its “5 minutes of fame”, as they say, to show the international community that they are wealthy and relevant. Tony Manfred from the Business Insider wrote an article titled 14 Reasons Why The Qatar World Cup Is Going To Be A Disaster that brings up a lot of the main problems with the controversy that I’m going to discuss. The first issue he mentions is the International Trade Union Confederation’s report that an estimated 4,000 migrant workers from Nepal

1272-ASP_WM2022and India will die as a result of the harsh and dangerous conditions presented during construction of these massive stadiums. It has been recorded that over 1,200 migrant workers have already died. Manfred’s next two reasons trace bribery allegations directly to specific FIFA officials, most of whom have stepped down since then after having received millions of dollars from suspicious sources. Reason number five, ten, eleven, and twelve relate to the same issue, that issue being that it is 120 degrees during the summer in Qatar. Apparently Qatar promised to build futuristic air-conditioned facilities during the bidding process that have now been confirmed as impossible. With that, the games would have to be moved to winter which leads to an entirely new mess. If the games were in winter the European club leagues would have to reschedule their entire season, which results in needing to renegotiate hundreds of TV contracts. Players, especially the world class ones that play in Europe, benefit a lot more from playing for their club teams so they may just not participate in the World Cup at all. Manfred goes on to list a few more reasons as to why the Qatari World Cup would be a disaster but I believe I’ve made his and my point. The World Cup just can’t be held in Qatar for humanitarian, money, and practical reasons. I believe there should be a rebidding process that only gives countries with the least amount of projected problems a chance. Anyways, let me know what you think in the comment section. Do you think it’ll all workout? Do you agree or disagree with Manfred and myself? If so, why?

Source: http://www.businessinsider.sg/qatar-world-cup-problems-2014-4/


5 thoughts on “Did Qatar Cheat?

  1. Like you stated in the beginning sentences, I didn’t know much about this problem. Are there systems in place that will not allow countries to be chosen simply by bribery? I would have thought that a world organization like FIFA would have ways to make sure countries are not bribing the officials to host the world cup.

  2. It amazes me how the loss of 1,200 migrate workers is overshadowed by the importance of soccer. It seems like they will do anything to be the host of the 2022 FIFA World Cup, which is still eight years away. How was Qatar even a qualifying location because it seems like there is a lot of logical evidence against Qatar as the host of the cup. This just shows that power and especially money goes a long way. I wonder if the Qatar officials actually thought they could get away with accepting the bribe?

  3. I can’t believe that Qatar thinks they can get away with submitting plans that are unrealistic and putting 1,200 migrant workers under such harsh living conditions. This is a human rights issue right there! We went through something similar when the Olympics were held in SoChi this year. The facilities were not completed by the time of the opening ceremonies and people felt like they were not living in proper living conditions for the athletes. If this is something that happened with the athletes, did we ever stop to wonder what it must have been like for the workers that were building the faciltities? Do any of the world sports organizations committees stop to think about any of these things before awarding it to host countries? Maybe they should be rethinking the way that they do their bidding process.

  4. The immigrant worker situation is much more serious than the mainstream media and Qatar would like to admit. Agree with you completely. These workers are living in horrid conditions, underpaid, and over worked. Should the UN or FIFA be the ones to stop this? Not sure if this is just a soccer issue.
    On the actual sports side of things, if the Europeans have such big sway do you think the location will actually change? I wonder what other country would host. Hopefully a less controversial one that Qatar and formerly Brazil, whose slums are infamous.

  5. I agree that a winter World Cup would cause a mayhem in the soccer world. I could not even imagine the idea. Also, Qatar not having any presence in the soccer world does make it interesting why they would fight for the World Cup bid and raises an eye brow on the scandal?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s