Homeland: A Television Series Making Waves

Deputing in October of 2011, the television series, Homeland has been in the spotlight for a variety of topics over the past two years. In its first season, critical acclaim was given to this drama/thriller series that is based off an Israeli series, entitled Hatufim (Prisoners of War). This first season earned the hit series the 2012 Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Drama Series, the Golden Globe Award for Best Television Series – Drama, and the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actor and Lead Actress. This past September was the premiere of its second season, and just within the past two weeks the renewal of the series for a third season was solidified. With all of these positives being the past reasons Homeland was the topic of discussion, the tides have now started to turn to a more controversial discussion on a global scale.

“Militants carrying assault weapons clear the area around a street, shouting in Arabic for people to get out of the way. A jeep pulls up: The world’s No. 1 jihadi has arrived for a meeting with top Hezbollah commanders. On rooftops, U.S. snipers crouch unseen, the kingpin in their crosshairs at last.”

This above scene is a description by the Huffington Post on a recent episode in the second season of the series. This town where the violence is portrayed as taking place is Beirut, Lebanon. In a time where tensions are already at a heightened level, scenes such as these have not helped to reconcile the relations that are at odds in the Middle East.

Fadi Abboud is the current Lebanese Tourism Minister who was so furious with these depictions of Beirut that there has been much speculation that lawsuits may be in the near future. Many Lebanese have been dissatisfied with the portrayal because they believe it does not accurately reflect reality. On a pure realistic level, this statement is very accurate because the scene was not even filmed in Lebanon. To add salt to the wound, the urban scenes where snipers are roaming and violence is typical were filmed in Israel. With close attention, this is given away in the episode by the landmarks, license plates and even a sign in Hebrew letters.

There have been many reactions to this recent debate. When Lebanese citizens were interviewed on their reaction to this situation, a variety of responses were received. Some were outraged that Israel stood in for Lebanon, others were indifferent and accepting that reality shouldn’t be expected from television, while yet others were horrified that Lebanon once again was only seen through a lens surrounded in violence.

Ronen Akerman/Showtime

As I was reading this, I couldn’t help but recall my personal experiences with our friends that visited from Lebanon. One of the comments that I repeatedly heard them say was that everyone here has such a misconception as to what their homeland is like. They have grass, they go shopping, and it’s more than just a plot of land, it’s beautiful. As I was hearing these first-hand accounts, I was able to break the assumptions I had subconsciously made. This led me to question- if a citizen has not had an experience or education that shows them the true Middle East, would they believe that every road is littered with guns and closely resembles the scenes on television?

Scenes such as these are very typical in the media and generalizations are made to appeal to a large audience. But at what price do we pay for these misconstrued realities? Some Lebanese citizens understood that you cannot take a television series to relay accurate information, thus not being offended. I would agree with this statement to a degree but what happens when these continual portrayals are the only perceptions some citizens receive? With the media choosing to only relay the violence, paired with misunderstood renderings of the same cities, the public eye is getting a heavy dose of one aspect of the country, not the country as a whole.

I found this debate over Homeland to be extremely pertinent to the issues facing our country. As we move on in trying to mend the relations in the Middle East, do the ‘little’ things such as these images need to be monitored and adjusted? From a citizen’s standpoint on both sides, how do you feel about this recent situation? Do people need to take this with a grain a salt and focus on the larger topics of interest, or is this a topic worth the debate? As the series continues, I will be extremely interested to see if another scene such as this is implemented and whether or not a lawsuit is filed.


3 thoughts on “Homeland: A Television Series Making Waves

  1. I have never seen the television show, but after reading your post I am interested! I was not aware that the show was based on an Israeli series (which is not surprising that America remade another countries television show or movie). Television shows based on current issues helps to increase awareness of issues without watching the news. It is unfortunate that our portrayal of reality seems to be unrealistic and not surprising. Whether it is accurate or not, at the very least it creates attention and awareness.

  2. I personally love the show Homeland. Yet, every time I have watched it since our Lebanese students have visited, I also keep wandering if the media plays up this misconception. From what the students said, Lebanon is a beautiful place and is there home. I feel that American especially the media play with how we view the Middle East. They make us picture run down buildings, deserts, and women with no rights. As much as I love this show, I do think that monitoring should be done to ensure people see the correct view of the Middle East.

  3. I personally feel that a misconception is in place for a reason. Honestly i feel that American Media portrays the Middle East as a run down war zone desert for strategic reasons.I believe that United States citizens think that it is a free-for-all in the Middle East. Moreover, the media portraying this idea allows U.S. citizens to convey a perception on the Middle East as well as make them feel safer living in the United States. Furthermore, government is about keeping the people calm and proud in the United States and media does the same thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s